Breaking down the Castillo decision

By JEFFREY WARNER
Staff Writter — jwarner@highhopesblog.com
_______

Andy Reid certainly made an out of the box decision, promoting o-line coach Juan Castillo to defensive coordinator. (Courtesy Philly.com)

It has been a little over two and half weeks since the Eagles fired Sean McDermott as their defensive coordinator. All the speculation was that the mystery man would be someone coaching in the big game.

Well, after a long, hard search they have found their man. But it’s not someone you would expect the Eagles to hire to take over this mediocre defense.

The team announced Wednesday afternoon after all the interviews and candidates, they have decided to go in house and promote offensive line coach Juan Castillo and convert him into the new Eagles’ defensive coordinator. And Coach Andy Reid feels he is the right man for the job.

“We are very excited to introduce Juan Castillo as the new defensive coordinator of the Philadelphia Eagles.  Obviously, this is a great opportunity, not only for the Eagles, but also for Juan. It’s a tribute to the hard work, the diligence and the kind of football coach he is. I think if you have the opportunity to talk to any player, if you have an opportunity to talk to any coach that has been a Philadelphia Eagle, and many coaches throughout the league, what might seem a little strange is just a very confident move, and one that will take our defense to another level. I look forward to that combination of [defensive line coach] Jim Washburn and Juan Castillo and the new additions that we’ll add here with time.”

 

The move is somewhat shocking to Eagles’ nation. After all, Castillo hasn’t coached defense in over 20 years and it was at a high school. But Castillo is excited to make the transition.

“I’m a defensive guy. I think all the front seven guys know that because I’m always talking to them like that,” Castillo said Wednesday. “Coach and I, through the years, we talk about things like that. I would say, ‘Coach, if I could ever go back on defense I would be tough because I understand what offenses are trying to do—the run game, the protections, the passing game. That would be an asset for me.”

Castillo joined the Eagles in 1995 as an assistant coach to Ray Rhodes but before that he played linebacker in college and in the USFL for the San Antonio Gunslingers. He then started his coaching career for high schools and colleges before interning with various NFL teams that eventually landed him a job in Philadelphia.

EAGLE JEFF’S TAKE:

It’s a strange and tough move on the Eagles part to bring someone in house that has been around this organization for some time now. They need a new identity. They need someone that isn’t used to Andy Reid’s philosophy and as they said during the entire press conference, “it’s a risky move.”

Risky doesn’t even explain it. You bring a guy that hasn’t coached defensively for over 20 years to all of a sudden throw him in there and expect success? It’s going to be a lot to ask for and this team and the coaching staff is already under a lot scrutiny and this decision to hire Castillo to coach the defense is just going to make it worse.

The only positive side of things is his knowledge on the offensive side of the ball with the offensive line. Like their techniques and movements to hopefully him and newly hired defensive line coach, Jim Washburn can coach and develop this young defensive line to read the offense better into making plays and getting to the quarterback which they lacked so much last season from their front four.

I don’t know how he is going to be able to fix and coach a secondary that was completely horrendous last season giving up a franchise record 31 touchdown passes.

Castillo will also be stuck with an inexperienced linebacking corps that lacks the fundamentals and discipline to make plays by recognizing what the opposing team’s offense is doing to them.

To really make this move work, they need to get playmakers this offseason and get experienced coaches to help Castillo along the way. Right now they are still without a secondary coach. Hopefully they can get the right man in here for the job and the right personnel.

Right now, the way things are going Andy is on a short leash and if this decision and off-season doesn’t pan out and they fall flat on their faces again next season, Eagles management might think it’s time for a change and slam the door in Reid’s face and on his way out of town.

 

It has been a little over two and half weeks since the Eagles fired Sean McDermott as their defensive coordinator. All the speculation was it was going to be someone that is coaching in the big game. Well after a long hard search they have found their man. But it’s not someone you would expect them to hire to take over this mediocre defense.

They announced Wednesday evening after all the interviews and candidates, they have decided to go in house and promote offensive line coach Juan Castillo and convert him into the new Eagles’ defensive coordinator. And Coach Andy Reid feels he is the right man for the job.

“We are very excited to introduce Juan Castillo as the new defensive coordinator of the Philadelphia Eagles. Obviously, this is a great opportunity, not only for the Eagles, but also for Juan. It’s a tribute to the hard work, the diligence and the kind of football coach he is. I think if you have the opportunity to talk to any player, if you have an opportunity to talk to any coach that has been a Philadelphia Eagle, and many coaches throughout the league, what might seem a little strange is just a very confident move, and one that will take our defense to another level. I look forward to that combination of [defensive line coach] Jim Washburn and Juan Castillo and the new additions that we’ll add here with time.”

The move is somewhat shocking to Eagles’ nation as Castillo has worked for the Eagles the past 13 seasons coaching the offensive line. He has developed a lot of nobodies into superstars and pro bowlers and was considered one of the top assistants and o-line coaches in the game. He hasn’t coached anything defense in over 20 years which was a def. coordinator position for a high school in Texas. But Castillo is excited to make the transition.

“I’m a defensive guy. I think all the front seven guys know that because I’m always talking to them like that. Coach and I, through the years, we talk about things like that. I would say, ‘Coach, if I could ever go back on defense I would be tough because I understand what offenses are trying to do—the run game, the protections, the passing game. That would be an asset for me.”

Castillo joined the Eagles in 1995 as an assistant coach to Ray Rhodes but before that he played linebacker in college and in the USFL for the San Antonio Gunslingers. He then started his coaching career for high schools and colleges before interning with various NFL teams that eventually landed him a job in Philadelphia.

Now for the man who is taking over for Castillo, they have been able to convince legendary lineman coach Howard Mudd to come out of retirement to coach a offensive line group that was plagued by injuries and were inconsistent all season long.

Mudd has coached 36 years of experience, most recently with the Indianapolis Colts from 1998-2009 where he allowed a league low 227 sacks in that span with also leading the league in the category six times.  And he has helped lineman like center Jeff Saturday and guard Tarik Glenn into pro bowlers which have combined seven trips between the two.

My take on the situation: It’s a strange and tough move on the Eagles part to bring someone in house that has been around this organization for some time now. They need a new identity. They need someone that isn’t use to Andy Reid’s philosophy and as they said during the entire press conference,” it’s a risky move.”

Risky doesn’t even explain it. You bring a guy that hasn’t coached defensively for over 20 years to all of a sudden throw him in there and expect success? It’s going to be a lot to ask for and this team and the coaching staff is already under a lot scrutiny and this decision to hire Castillo to coach the defense is just going to make it worse.

The only positive side of things is his knowledge on the offensive side of the ball with the offensive line. Like their techniques and movements to hopefully him and newly hired defensive line coach, Jim Washburn can coach and develop this young defensive line to read the offense better into making plays and getting to the quarterback which they lacked so much last season from their front four.

Its just I don’t know how he is going to be able to fix and coach a secondary that was completely horrendous last season giving up a franchise record 31 touchdown passes. And an inexperience linebacking core that lacks the fundamentals and discipline to make plays by recognizing what the opposing team’s offense is doing to them. To really make this move work, they need to get playmakers this offseason and get the experience coaches to help Castillo along the way. Right now they are still without a secondary coach. Hopefully they can get the right man in here for the job and the right personal.

Right now way things are going Andy is on a short leash and if this decision and offseason doesn’t pan out and they fall flat on their faces again next season, Eagles management might think it’s time for a change and slam the door in Reid’s face and on his way out of town.

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under Editorial, Jeffrey Warner

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s